classified | jobs | real estate | rentals | cars | shopping

travel | education | weddings | movies | dining register | log in | log out | help, Raleigh, NC Site Updated:  8:29 AM | TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 10, 2004 
Home News You're in Business Sports Features Editorial Help






Multimedia Gallery

Edwards won't let rivals own foreign policy
Two of Sen. John Edwards' rivals are playing up something he can't: foreign-policy experience.

Look to future before selling Dix, state urged
Prime Raleigh real estate seen as prime opportunity to do good.

50 said killed in Iraq car bombing
A car bomb exploded this morning at a police station in a town south of Baghdad.

Primary put off till July
Democrats will have presidential caucuses April 17 in light of delay to allow federal review of state districts.

Road Worrier: Helmets, liberties: on collision course?
Legislative effort explores possible changes to state motorcycle laws.

Student book tells tales of struggle
On Monday, student leaders from UNC campuses presented a book that details the impacts of proposed tuition increases and budget cuts.

Wolfpack propelled into poll
With a 7-2 record and a solid second-place spot in the ACC, N.C. State returns to the AP top 25 after a brief early appearance.

Judge drops ACC in suit
Big East suffers setback in case.

China pulling along neighbor
Many Japanese companies are profiting from China's hunger for steel and construction materials, cell phones, plasma TVs and autos.

Free trade debated at forum
Proponents of trade restrictions say the state's textile industry is doomed without them.

Tuesday, February 10, 2004 6:51AM EST

Executives cynical about earnings

By EMERY P. DALESIO, The Associated Press

DURHAM -- Three-quarters of business executives say they massage earnings reports to meet or beat Wall Street expectations and would sacrifice shareholder value to keep earnings sloping up smoothly, according to a survey released Monday.

The study of 401 senior financial executives by researchers at Duke University and the University of Washington found that 55 percent would delay starting a project to avoid missing an earnings target. Four out of five executives said they would defer maintenance and research spending to meet earnings targets.
The preference for smooth earnings growth instead of even slight variations is so strong that 78 percent of the surveyed executives would give up economic value in exchange, the study said.

"I was shocked by the honesty of the executives' responses. There was no cover-up -- they are telling it like it is," said Campbell R. Harvey, an international business professor at Duke.

Edward Ketz, an accounting professor at Penn State and author of the book "Hidden Financial Risk: Understanding Off-Balance Sheet Accounting," said the study was less a surprise than an indication of how cynically executives treat earnings reports.

"You wonder whether they're looking at the long-term effects of these things by making short-term decisions," Ketz said.

Karl J. Schulze, a former corporate chief financial officer and now head of the Los Angeles forensic accounting firm of Schulze Haynes, said that attitudes expressed in the survey are prevalent in the business world.

"Long-term shareholder value has traditionally been sacrificed for short-term earnings, especially since most executive compensation packages have been, and continue to be, weighted toward near-term performance rather than creation of long-term value," he said.

The executives responding to the study resort to managing earnings because they fear running afoul of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, passed in 2002 after revelations that Enron manipulated earnings with accounting tricks, said Shiva Rajgopal of the University of Washington Business School in Seattle.

"They apparently prefer to use economic levers, such as deferring needed maintenance and delaying profitable investment projects," he said.

The researchers said the executives managed earnings targets because the stock market punishes even a small miss in earnings.

"As one CFO put it, everyone manages earnings to hit the target, so missing an earnings target is seen as an indicator of more widespread problems -- like seeing one cockroach, you know there are 100 behind the wall," said Duke finance professor John Graham, one of the study's co-authors.

In contrast, say the researchers, if a firm delivers stable earnings and meets or exceeds earnings targets, it builds credibility within the financial market, reduces the perceived risk of its stock and enhances the external reputation of the firm's management.

Executives say that many decisions are effectively forced on them by the market's myopic focus on earnings, researchers said. "Our interviews revealed that CFOs do not like the system, but they are forced to play the game or risk losing their jobs," Rajgopal said.


printer friendly
printer friendly version

send story to a friend
send this story to a friend

email list
subscribe to our e-mail lists

get news, weather, movies on your PDA